Peyton Manning thought he was being funny by hazing the pro bowl rookie Jay Cutler. His prank was that he threw Cutler’s diabetes monitor into the pool. However it seems that wasn’t the original plan.

Here’s how it happened, courtesy of the Denver Post:

The gang of Pro Bowl football players had been gathered around the tables, swapping stories, when suddenly the Broncos’ quarterback had 300-pound Nick Mangold pushing from one side, 310-pound Kris Dielmanholding the other and his cell phone swindled into the hands of a coy Peyton Manning.

Cutler’s radar had gone up, but he never had a chance.

Splash!

“We gave him a Pro Bowl baptism,” said Dielman, the star offensive guard of the rival San Diego Chargers

Great fun. Big laughs. There was just one problem. Cutler is a Type 1 diabetic, and in his pocket was his blood-sugar monitor.

“That was a prank where I thought we were smart enough to get the cellphone out of his pocket,” Dielman said. “But then, ‘Oops.’ “

I’m sure Manning felt bad after finding out “what” he had thrown. Sometime pranks go bad. Luckily, I’m pretty sure Cutler has enough money to buy a new one.